Question:
Who was or is the best manager in english football history?
Gerard M
2009-02-02 16:36:41 UTC
Who was or is the best manager in english football history?
23 answers:
Matthew K
2009-02-02 16:52:47 UTC
it all depends on what you class as best. winning most trophies and that's probably Alex Ferguson and he's probably the best in the way of trophies around at the moment.

Shankly and Sir Bob Paisley took liverpool from a small team to the most successful english club ever.

In terms of managers at the moment you have to look at the likes of fergie, benitez in the sheer class of their football and where they have their teams in the league.

wenger has made some awesome signings given the money he has had on offer. henry pires bergkamp spring to mind.

but one of the best in my mind is Phil Brown who took hull city up to the premier league and has (i think its safe to say) kept them there. plus some of his methods (marching the players onto the pitch at halftime to give them a kick up the ****) have been magnificent.

In short however the best manager in english football history is probs either shanks or sir bob. but the best around at the moment is fergie
anonymous
2009-02-02 16:57:37 UTC
My top candidates would be Bob Paisley, Sir Alex Ferguson and Brian Clough.



Bob Paisley may have won 4 European Cups but I believe that Fergie winning 2 and the countless Premierships and other cups is a better acievement. I feel this because I believe that European football is overall a lot stronger now than in the past. Also, the number of teams he has built and nurtured has to be admired.

Clough managed to win European Cups with Forrest and his achievements at Derby were also amazing.



I personally believe in Fergie, however it's all open to debate.
unclesox
2009-02-02 17:58:17 UTC
Brian Clough



At Derby County he took over in May 1967 when the club finished 17th in the 2nd Division.

Two years later the club won the division and gained promotion to the top flight.

Derby followed that up by finishing 4th and 9th before becoming English champions in 1972.

A year later they reached the European Cup semifinals where they controversially lost to the "cheating bastards" of Juventus (Clough's own words).

So in the space of five seasons they went from a 2nd Division club to English champions to European Cup semifinalists.



At Forest Clough took over in January 1975 when the club were struggling to avoid dropping into the 3rd Division. They eventually finished 16th in Division 2.

Two years later in 1977 Clough guided Forest to the top flight when they finished 3rd in the 2nd Division.

The following season they became league champions.

A year after that they won the European Cup and successfully defended the trophy the next year.

Once again he had taken a 2nd Division side and made them English champions.

From 1976 to 1980 he turned a 2nd Division team into two-time European champions.



And in each circumstance he had limited funds and no prominant youth academy to help build his teams.





Classic Clough...



"They say Rome wasn't built in a day, but I never had that particular job."



"I may not be the best manager in the business. But I'm certainly in the top one."



Indeed.
Tony F
2009-02-02 18:02:47 UTC
Deffo Bob Paisley, apart from the fact he won countless trophies in a shorter time frame than Ferguson he had a big hand in helping setting up the winning format under Shankley.

Fergie 2nd though

And Phil Brown 3rd....(my home town team)
anonymous
2009-02-03 00:34:30 UTC
Take your pick from the Scots, and the one English legend of course



Jock Stein

Matt Busby

Alex Ferguson

Bill Shankley

Brian Clough

Bob Paisley
Ash
2009-02-02 18:58:14 UTC
Sir Alex Furgeson
anonymous
2009-02-03 03:23:46 UTC
Bob Paisley
anonymous
2009-02-02 22:12:20 UTC
Sir Alex Ferguson...

it's the best manager in the world.....

and for Manchester United
Martyn R
2009-02-02 16:52:27 UTC
Sir Alex Ferguson is the most successful on paper. Then Bob Paisley.
anonymous
2009-02-02 21:01:22 UTC
'Sir' Bob Paisley.



6 League titles,3 European Cups,1 UEFA Cup & 3 League Cups in 9 years.
Not Fit
2009-02-02 20:01:26 UTC
Brian Clough for all the reasons "unclesox" says . Plus he also achieved superstar status as a player till injury forced early retirement !
anonymous
2009-02-02 18:46:43 UTC
Ruud Gillit or Avram Grant
arthur brain
2009-02-03 05:43:27 UTC
hate to say it but ..

alex ferguson i dont like man u but you can not argue with his track record he is the best and probally will be for some time in the record books
anonymous
2009-02-02 17:52:58 UTC
Bob Paisley.Did what ferguson did in half the time with half the money,Nice guy too.
?
2009-02-02 19:57:52 UTC
LOL whoever said Avram Grant he was a disapointment...Joe Kinnear no doubt don't argue with me
Luke H
2009-02-02 16:39:53 UTC
Alf Ramsey or Sir Matt Busby.
anonymous
2009-02-02 21:28:19 UTC
Bill Shankly!
anonymous
2009-02-02 16:48:30 UTC
BOB PAISLEY and when someone else wins 4 european cups and countless other honours then and only then can they state a claim
*** Stands by Mourinho!
2009-02-03 02:52:13 UTC
SAF





dR bad

without a shadow...
anonymous
2009-02-03 09:15:27 UTC
joe harvey or speical k
Bob B
2009-02-02 16:44:00 UTC
noooo its definently bob vila
anonymous
2009-02-03 04:05:25 UTC
gareth southgate
Eddie Boi
2009-02-02 17:21:07 UTC
Bubsy or Fergie...need look no more.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...